Tag: Framework

C4 Architecture Model – Detailed Explanation

1 Comment

The C4 model, developed by Simon Brown, is a framework for visualizing software architecture at various levels of detail. It emphasizes the use of hierarchical diagrams to represent different aspects and views of a system, providing a comprehensive understanding for various stakeholders. The model’s name, C4, stands for Context, Containers, Components, and Code, each representing a different level of architectural abstraction.

Levels of the C4 Model

1. Context (Level 1)

Purpose: To provide a high-level overview of the system and its environment.

  • The System Context diagram is a high-level view of your software system.
  • It shows your software system as the central part, and any external systems and users that your system interacts with.
  • It should be technology agnostic, and the focus on the people and software systems instead of low-level details.
  • The intended audience for the System Context Diagram is everybody. If you can show it to non-technical people and they are able to understand it, then you know you’re on the right track.

Key Elements:

  • System: The primary system under consideration.
  • External Systems: Other systems that the primary system interacts with.
  • Users: Human actors or roles that interact with the system.

Diagram Features:

  • Scope: Shows the scope and boundaries of the system within its environment.
  • Relationships: Illustrates relationships between the system, external systems, and users.
  • Simplification: Focuses on high-level interactions, ignoring internal details.

Example: An online banking system context diagram might show:

  • The banking system itself.
  • External systems like payment gateways, credit scoring agencies, and notification services.
  • Users such as customers, bank employees, and administrators.

More Extensive Detail:

  • Primary System: Represents the main application or service being documented.
  • Boundaries: Defines the limits of what the system covers.
  • Purpose: Describes the main functionality and goals of the system.
  • External Systems: Systems outside the primary system that interact with it.
  • Dependencies: Systems that the primary system relies on for specific functionalities (e.g., third-party APIs, external databases).
  • Interdependencies: Systems that rely on the primary system (e.g., partner applications).
  • Users: Different types of users who interact with the system.
  • Roles: Specific roles that users may have, such as Admin, Customer, Support Agent.
  • Interactions: The nature of interactions users have with the system (e.g., login, data entry, report generation).

2. Containers (Level 2)

When you zoom into one software system, you get to the Container diagram.

Purpose: To break down the system into its major containers, showing their interactions.

  • Your software system is comprised of multiple running parts – containers.
  • A container can be a:
    • Web application
    • Single-page application
    • Database
    • File system
    • Object store
    • Message broker
  • You can look at a container as a deployment unit that executes code or stores data.
  • The Container diagram shows the high-level view of the software architecture and the major technology choices.
  • The Container diagram is intended for technical people inside and outside of the software development team:
    • Operations/support staff
    • Software architects
    • Developers

Key Elements:

  • Containers: Executable units or deployable artifacts (e.g., web applications, databases, microservices).
  • Interactions: Communication and data flow between containers and external systems.

Diagram Features:

  • Runtime Environment: Depicts the containers and their runtime environments.
  • Technology Choices: Shows the technology stacks and platforms used by each container.
  • Responsibilities: Describes the responsibilities of each container within the system.

Example: For the online banking system:

  • Containers could include a web application, a mobile application, a backend API, and a database.
  • The web application might interact with the backend API for business logic and the database for data storage.
  • The mobile application might use a different API optimized for mobile clients.

More Extensive Detail:

  • Web Application:
    • Technology Stack: Frontend framework (e.g., Angular, React), backend language (e.g., Node.js, Java).
    • Responsibilities: User interface, handling user requests, client-side validation.
  • Mobile Application:
    • Technology Stack: Native (e.g., Swift for iOS, Kotlin for Android) or cross-platform (e.g., React Native, Flutter).
    • Responsibilities: User interface, handling user interactions, offline capabilities.
  • Backend API:
    • Technology Stack: Server-side framework (e.g., Spring Boot, Express.js), programming language (e.g., Java, Node.js).
    • Responsibilities: Business logic, data processing, integrating with external services.
  • Database:
    • Technology Stack: Type of database (e.g., SQL, NoSQL), specific technology (e.g., PostgreSQL, MongoDB).
    • Responsibilities: Data storage, data retrieval, ensuring data consistency and integrity.

3. Components (Level 3)

Next you can zoom into an individual container to decompose it into its building blocks.

Purpose: To further decompose each container into its key components and their interactions.

  • The Component diagram show the individual components that make up a container:
    • What each of the components are
    • The technology and implementation details
  • The Component diagram is intended for software architects and developers.

Key Elements:

  • Components: Logical units within a container, such as services, modules, libraries, or APIs.
  • Interactions: How these components interact within the container.

Diagram Features:

  • Internal Structure: Shows the internal structure and organization of each container.
  • Detailed Responsibilities: Describes the roles and responsibilities of each component.
  • Interaction Details: Illustrates the detailed interaction between components.

Example: For the backend API container of the online banking system:

  • Components might include an authentication service, an account management module, a transaction processing service, and a notification handler.
  • The authentication service handles user login and security.
  • The account management module deals with account-related operations.
  • The transaction processing service manages financial transactions.
  • The notification handler sends alerts and notifications to users.

More Extensive Detail:

  • Authentication Service:
    • Responsibilities: User authentication, token generation, session management.
    • Interactions: Interfaces with the user interface components, interacts with the database for user data.
  • Account Management Module:
    • Responsibilities: Managing user accounts, updating account information, retrieving account details.
    • Interactions: Interfaces with the authentication service for user validation, interacts with the transaction processing service.
  • Transaction Processing Service:
    • Responsibilities: Handling financial transactions, validating transactions, updating account balances.
    • Interactions: Interfaces with the account management module, interacts with external payment gateways.
  • Notification Handler:
    • Responsibilities: Sending notifications (e.g., emails, SMS) to users, managing notification templates.
    • Interactions: Interfaces with the transaction processing service to send transaction alerts, interacts with external notification services.

4. Code (Level 4)

Finally, you can zoom into each component to show how it is implemented with code, typically using a UML class diagram or an ER diagram.

Purpose: To provide detailed views of the codebase, focusing on specific components or classes.

  • This level is rarely used as it goes into too much technical detail for most use cases. However, there are supplementary diagrams that can be useful to fill in missing information by showcasing:
    • Sequence of events
    • Deployment information
    • How systems interact at a higher level
  • It’s only recommended for the most important or complex components.
  • Of course, the target audience are software architects and developers.

Key Elements:

  • Classes: Individual classes, methods, or functions within a component.
  • Relationships: Detailed relationships like inheritance, composition, method calls, or data flows.

Diagram Features:

  • Detailed Code Analysis: Offers a deep dive into the code structure and logic.
  • Code-Level Relationships: Illustrates how classes and methods interact at a code level.
  • Implementation Details: Shows specific implementation details and design patterns used.

Example: For the transaction processing service in the backend API container:

  • Classes might include Transaction, TransactionProcessor, Account, and NotificationService.
  • The TransactionProcessor class might have methods for initiating, validating, and completing transactions.
  • Relationships such as TransactionProcessor calling methods on the Account class to debit or credit funds.

More Extensive Detail:

  • Transaction Class:
    • Attributes: transactionId, amount, timestamp, status.
    • Methods: validate(), execute(), rollback().
    • Responsibilities: Representing a financial transaction, ensuring data integrity.
  • TransactionProcessor Class:
    • Attributes: transactionQueue, auditLog.
    • Methods: processTransaction(transaction), validateTransaction(transaction), completeTransaction(transaction).
    • Responsibilities: Processing transactions, managing transaction flow, logging transactions.
  • Account Class:
    • Attributes: accountId, balance, accountHolder.
    • Methods: debit(amount), credit(amount), getBalance().
    • Responsibilities: Managing account data, updating balances, providing account information.
  • NotificationService Class:
    • Attributes: notificationQueue, emailTemplate, smsTemplate.
    • Methods: sendEmailNotification(recipient, message), sendSMSNotification(recipient, message).
    • Responsibilities: Sending notifications to users, managing notification templates, handling notification queues.

Benefits of the C4 Model

  • Clarity and Focus:
    • Provides a clear separation of concerns by breaking down the system into different levels of abstraction.
    • Each diagram focuses on a specific aspect, avoiding information overload.
  • Consistency and Standardization:
    • Offers a standardized approach to documenting architecture, making it easier to maintain consistency across diagrams.
    • Facilitates comparison and review of different systems using the same visual language.
  • Enhanced Communication:
    • Improves communication within development teams and with external stakeholders by providing clear, concise, and visually appealing diagrams.
    • Helps in onboarding new team members by offering an easy-to-understand representation of the system.
  • Comprehensive Documentation:
    • Ensures comprehensive documentation of the system architecture, covering different levels of detail.
    • Supports various documentation needs, from high-level overviews to detailed technical specifications.

Practical Usage of the C4 Model

  • Starting with Context:
    • Begin with a high-level context diagram to understand the system’s scope, external interactions, and primary users.
    • Use this diagram to set the stage for more detailed diagrams.
  • Defining Containers:
    • Break down the system into its major containers, showing how they interact and are deployed.
    • Highlight the technology choices and responsibilities of each container.
  • Detailing Components:
    • For each container, create a component diagram to illustrate the internal structure and interactions.
    • Focus on how functionality is divided among components and how they collaborate.
  • Exploring Code:
    • If needed, delve into the code level for specific components to provide detailed documentation and analysis.
    • Use class or sequence diagrams to show detailed code-level relationships and logic.

Example Scenario: Online Banking System

Context Diagram:

  • System: Online Banking System
  • External Systems: Payment Gateway, Credit Scoring Agency, Notification Service
  • Users: Customers, Bank Employees, Administrators
  • Description: Shows how customers interact with the banking system, which in turn interacts with external systems for payment processing, credit scoring, and notifications.

Containers Diagram:

  • Containers: Web Application, Mobile Application, Backend API, Database
  • Interactions: The web application and mobile application interact with the backend API. The backend API communicates with the database and external systems.
  • Technology Stack: The web application might be built with Angular, the mobile application with React Native, the backend API with Spring Boot, and the database with PostgreSQL.

Components Diagram:

  • Web Application Components: Authentication Service, User Dashboard, Transaction Module
  • Backend API Components: Authentication Service, Account Management Module, Transaction Processing Service, Notification Handler
  • Interactions: The Authentication Service in both the web application and backend API handles user authentication and security. The Transaction Module in the web application interacts with the Transaction Processing Service in the backend API.

Code Diagram:

  • Classes: Transaction, TransactionProcessor, Account, NotificationService
  • Methods: The TransactionProcessor class has methods for initiating, validating, and completing transactions. The NotificationService class has methods for sending notifications.
  • Relationships: The TransactionProcessor calls methods on the Account class to debit or credit funds. It also calls the NotificationService to send transaction alerts.

Conclusion

The C4 model is a powerful tool for visualising and documenting software architecture. By providing multiple levels of abstraction, it ensures that stakeholders at different levels of the organisation can understand the system. From high-level overviews to detailed code analysis, the C4 model facilitates clear communication, consistent documentation, and comprehensive understanding of complex software systems.

Driving Digital Transformation: Insights from ‘Project to Product’

Leave a comment

Synopsis

“Project to Product: How to Survive and Thrive in the Age of Digital Disruption with the Flow Framework” by Mik Kersten presents a revolutionary approach for organisations navigating the complex landscape of digital transformation. The book addresses a critical challenge faced by many companies: the shift from traditional project-based work models to product-centric models in order to better adapt to the fast-paced, technology-driven market.

Kersten introduces the Flow Framework™ as a solution to this challenge. The framework is designed to bridge the gap between the business and IT, enabling organisations to thrive in the digital age by focusing on value delivery rather than just project completion. The author argues that in the era of software becoming a crucial part of every aspect of the business, companies need to transform their management and development practices to stay competitive.

The book is divided into several parts, beginning with an analysis of why the traditional project management approaches are failing to meet the demands of modern digital business. Kersten then delves into the details of the Flow Framework™, explaining its core components: Flow Items, Flow Metrics, and Flow Distribution. These elements help organisations to measure and manage the flow of business value from ideation to customer delivery.

“Project to Product” emphasises the importance of focusing on products rather than projects, advocating for a shift in how teams are organised, how work is prioritised, and how success is measured. By adopting the Flow Framework™, businesses can improve their software delivery performance, enhance strategic decision-making, and ultimately, increase their competitiveness in the digital era.

The book provides actionable insights, real-world examples, and practical advice for leaders and practitioners aiming to transform their organisations by moving from project to product. Mik Kersten draws from his extensive experience in the field to guide readers through the journey of digital transformation, making “Project to Product” an essential read for anyone involved in software development, IT management, or organisational change.

The Flow Framework Explained

The Flow Framework™, introduced by Mik Kersten in “Project to Product,” is a strategic model designed to aid organisations in navigating the complexities of digital transformation. It aims to shift the focus from traditional project-centric operations to a product-centric approach, aligning IT and software development processes with business outcomes. The framework is particularly geared towards enhancing how businesses deliver value in an era dominated by digital technologies. Here’s a breakdown of its key components and principles:

Core Components

  • Flow Items: These are the work items that move through the IT value stream, categorised into Features (new business value), Defects (quality issues), Risks (security, compliance, and technical debt), and Debts (technical debt reduction). The categorisation helps organisations prioritise and track the value delivery.
  • Flow Metrics: The framework introduces four key metrics to manage and measure the flow of work:
    • Flow Time: Measures the time taken from work initiation to delivery, providing insight into the overall responsiveness of the value stream.
    • Flow Velocity: Measures the number of flow items completed over a given period, indicating the speed of value delivery.
    • Flow Efficiency: Assesses the proportion of time flow items spend in active work versus waiting or blocked, highlighting process efficiency and waste.
    • Flow Load: Tracks the work in progress within the system, ensuring teams are not overburdened and can maintain a sustainable pace.
  • Flow Distribution: This component analyses the distribution of flow items across the different categories (Features, Defects, Risks, Debts), helping teams to balance their efforts and ensure a focus on delivering customer value while maintaining system health and compliance.

Principles

  • Product-Centric: Shifts the focus from managing projects to nurturing products, aligning IT work with business outcomes and customer value.
  • Feedback and Adaptation: Encourages rapid feedback loops within and between IT and business, fostering continuous improvement and adaptation to change.
  • Value Stream Management: Emphasises the importance of visualising and managing the entire value stream from idea to delivery, identifying bottlenecks and opportunities for optimisation.

Benefits

By implementing the Flow Framework™, organisations can achieve several key benefits:

  • Improved visibility into IT operations and their impact on business outcomes.
  • Enhanced alignment between IT and business strategies.
  • Increased efficiency and speed of software delivery.
  • Better prioritisation of work, focusing on delivering customer value.
  • A more agile and responsive IT organisation, capable of adapting to changes in the market and technology landscape.

The Flow Framework™ offers a comprehensive approach to managing and measuring IT and software development work, making it an essential tool for organisations looking to thrive in the digital age.

Key Learnings & Benefits

From “Project to Product” readers can derive several key learnings and benefits, particularly relevant to leaders and practitioners navigating digital transformations within their organisations. The book not only introduces the Flow Framework™ but also delves into the necessity of evolving from project-oriented to product-oriented IT and software development approaches. Here are the core takeaways and benefits:

Key Learnings:

  1. Shift from Project to Product: One of the main themes of the book is the critical shift that organisations must make from focusing on projects to concentrating on products. This shift enables a closer alignment with business outcomes and customer value.
  2. Introduction to the Flow Framework™: The book presents the Flow Framework™ as a methodology to enable this transition, providing a language and set of metrics for business and IT to communicate effectively and drive value delivery.
  3. Understanding Value Stream Management: Kersten emphasises the importance of value stream management, encouraging organisations to visualise and optimise the flow of value from idea to delivery. This is vital for identifying bottlenecks and improving delivery speed and quality.
  4. Emphasis on Continuous Feedback: The book highlights the necessity of establishing feedback loops to swiftly and efficiently adapt to changes, ensuring that product development is aligned with customer needs and market demands.
  5. Cultural Transformation: “Project to Product” underlines the need for a cultural shift within organisations, fostering an environment that supports continual learning, collaboration, and innovation.

Benefits:

  1. Enhanced Visibility and Alignment: By adopting the principles outlined in the book, organisations can achieve greater visibility into their IT operations and ensure that they are closely aligned with their business goals.
  2. Increased Efficiency and Agility: The Flow Framework™ helps organisations streamline their processes, reducing waste and enabling them to respond more quickly to market changes and customer needs.
  3. Improved Decision-Making: With clear metrics and a focus on value delivery, leaders can make more informed decisions about where to allocate resources and how to prioritise work.
  4. Competitive Advantage: Organisations that successfully shift from project to product and implement the Flow Framework™ can gain a significant competitive advantage by being more innovative, agile, and customer-focused.
  5. Sustainable Transformation: The book provides a roadmap for sustainable digital transformation, helping organisations navigate the challenges of the digital age and emerge more resilient and adaptable.

“Project to Product” offers valuable insights for any leader or practitioner involved in software development, IT management, or organisational change, providing a practical framework for navigating the complexities of digital transformation and driving long-term value.

Scrum of Scrums

Leave a comment

The Scrum of Scrums is a scaled agile framework used to coordinate the work of multiple Scrum teams working on the same product or project. It is a meeting or a communication structure that allows teams to discuss their progress, identify dependencies, and address any challenges that may arise during the development process. The Scrum of Scrums is often employed in large organisations where a single Scrum team may not be sufficient to deliver a complex product or project.

The primary purpose of the Scrum of Scrums is to facilitate coordination and communication among multiple Scrum teams. It ensures that all teams are aligned towards common goals and are aware of each other’s progress.

Here are some key aspects of the Scrum of Scrums:

Frequency:

  • The frequency of Scrum of Scrums meetings depends on the project’s needs, but they are often daily or multiple times per week to ensure timely issue resolution.
  • Shorter daily meetings focussing on progress, next steps and blockers can be substantiated by a longer weekly meeting covering an agenda of all projects and more detailed discussions.

Participants – Scrum Teams and Representatives:

  • In a large-scale project or programme, there are multiple Scrum teams working on different aspects of the product or project.
  • Each Scrum team is represented by one or more members (often the Scrum Masters or team leads) in the Scrum of Scrums meeting. Each team selects one or more representatives to attend the Scrum of Scrums meeting.
  • These representatives are typically Scrum Masters or team leads who can effectively communicate the status, challenges, and dependencies of their respective teams.
  • The purpose of these representatives is to share information about their team’s progress, discuss impediments, and collaborate on solutions.

Meeting Structure & Agenda:

  • The Scrum of Scrums meeting follows a structured agenda that may include updates on team progress, identification of impediments, discussion of cross-team dependencies, reviewing and updating the overall RAID log with associated mitigation action progress and and collaborative problem-solving.
  • A key focus of the Scrum of Scrums is identifying and addressing cross-team dependencies. Teams discuss how their work may impact or be impacted by the work of other teams, and they collaboratively find solutions to minimise bottlenecks and define a overall critical path / timeline for the project delivery.

Tools and Techniques:

  • While the Scrum of Scrums is often conducted through face-to-face meetings, organisations may use various tools and techniques for virtual collaboration, especially if teams are distributed geographically. Video conferencing, collaboration platforms, and digital boards are common aids.

Focus on Coordination:

  • The primary goal of the Scrum of Scrums is to facilitate communication and coordination among the different Scrum teams.
  • Teams discuss their plans, commitments, and any issues they are facing. This helps in identifying dependencies and potential roadblocks early on.

Problem Solving:

  • If there are impediments or issues that cannot be resolved within individual teams, the Scrum of Scrums provides a forum for collaborative problem-solving.
  • The focus is on finding solutions that benefit the overall project, rather than just individual teams.

Scaling Agile:

  • The Scrum of Scrums is in line with the agile principles of adaptability and collaboration. It allows organisations to scale agile methodologies effectively by maintaining the iterative and incremental nature of Scrum while accommodating the complexities of larger projects.

Information Flow: & Sharing

  • The Scrum of Scrums ensures that information flows smoothly between teams, preventing silos of knowledge and promoting transparency across the organisation.
  • The Scrum of Scrums provides a platform for teams to discuss impediments that go beyond the scope of individual teams. It fosters a collaborative environment where teams work together to solve problems and remove obstacles that hinder overall progress.
  • Transparency is a key element of agile development, and the Scrum of Scrums promotes it by ensuring that information flows freely between teams. This helps prevent misunderstandings, duplication of effort, and ensures that everyone is aware of the overall project status.

Adaptability:

  • The Scrum of Scrums is adaptable to the specific needs and context of the organisation. It can be tailored based on the size of the project, the number of teams involved, and the nature of the work being undertaken.
  • In summary, the Scrum of Scrums is a crucial component in the toolkit of agile methodologies for large-scale projects. It fosters collaboration, communication, and problem-solving across multiple Scrum teams, ensuring that the benefits of agile development are retained even in complex and extensive projects.

In Summary, the Scrum of Scrums is a crucial component in the toolkit of agile methodologies for large-scale projects. It fosters collaboration, communication, and problem-solving across multiple Scrum teams, ensuring that the benefits of agile development are retained even in complex and extensive projects.

It’s important to note that the Scrum of Scrums is just one of several techniques used for scaling agile. Other frameworks like SAFe (Scaled Agile Framework), LeSS (Large-Scale Scrum), and Nexus also provide structures for coordinating the work of multiple teams. The choice of framework depends on the specific needs and context of the organisation.